Round 14: TITANS vs ROOSTERS

The ignore button is a beautiful thing GT. I have just two on my ignore list and it’s made my life so much better here.

I use it on other forums but wasn't aware it existed here. Tbh I'd rather try and bury the hatchet first and if that doesn't work then yeah I'll definitely start using it.
 
I agree with every word gt101, and I have no problem ripping in to players when they don't perform. Like you I am sick of the mediocrity and the apparent lack of resolve to change. I was one in agreement with Shamus, in that, when the team doesn't perform by all means call players out but why add some names. Just me, but I think we should be a bit more loyal than that. As an aside, and I digress, when we get our women's team, if I come here and refer to the fat player in number 8 and add a name....well won't the pc brigade be all over me. That may be fair enough too, so should we hold the same standards to our nrl players?

As for you being called the negative one, a few of us have had that tag thrown at us over the years. Water off a ducks back. Hell, today I was even called humourless, but that was from Colonel (Wilhelm) Klink, so more water off a ducks back.

I think we have called a few male players fat but that was in direct reference to the amount of weight they were playing with. To identify someone as the fat chick in number 8 is different to referring to a player for their illegal off field discretions. If Greg Bird was at an age to come back some people would have issue with having a bloke here that allegedly glassed his girlfriend and may refer to him in that light. If Jarryd is ever found not guilty he would never not wear the moniker as being a rapist no matter what club he played for.
 
I think we have called a few male players fat but that was in direct reference to the amount of weight they were playing with. To identify someone as the fat chick in number 8 is different to referring to a player for their illegal off field discretions. If Greg Bird was at an age to come back some people would have issue with having a bloke here that allegedly glassed his girlfriend and may refer to him in that light. If Jarryd is ever found not guilty he would never not wear the moniker as being a rapist no matter what club he played for.

We most definitely should be looking to sign Chelsea Lenarduzzi to be our NRLW number 8.
 
Enough now lads this is not the place for such debate … why not create a Fight Club thread and then anybody can call anybody out and you can go there for this sort of stuff … that should make some good reading. The mods could even relocate postings there. Also there is such a thing as a Private Message for those who strongly believe somebody has wronged their sensitivity. And finally “sticks and stones …. “
 
Last edited:
When the re-signing of AJ was announced, GT101 complained that it was a year too long.

You are so humourless that even Titanic called you on it recently.

I like banter and cheeky jabs, deal with it instead of getting your panties in a bunch.

Hmmmm, i thought banter was meant to be funny. You're as funny as a heart attack.

Further to your other post, I don't hold grudges, nor do I have a recollection of your posts like you have with mine.

You can have the last word and then I suggest a truce. One thing we would agree on is that we want a great future for this club and we should concentrate on the footy side of things.
 
To give context...willhelm is referring to a meme whereby everything someone does annoys them. He's not calling MT a B word or suggesting he eats crackers.

In saying that, it's a meme that no one here probably knows or has heard of so it would've been worth explaining to not come across the way it did.

I'm going to delete the original post because of the way it has been interpreted and make the call that we stop this school playground BS...back on topic please
 
Well that’s good then. I’m glad it wasn’t meant that way to MT. Nonetheless I think the word starting with B and ending in H being used at all has long come to an end.
 
Last edited:
To give context...willhelm is referring to a meme whereby everything someone does annoys them. He's not calling MT a B word or suggesting he eats crackers.

In saying that, it's a meme that no one here probably knows or has heard of so it would've been worth explaining to not come across the way it did.

I'm going to delete the original post because of the way it has been interpreted and make the call that we stop this school playground BS...back on topic please

Cheers HS. I didn't take offence because I had no idea what he was on about.
 
Had some spare time so forced myself to re-watch some of the game last night. Looking at this last try that we (me included) threw a fair bit of shade at Sami for

LtrFQ0E.png


But lets instead focus on BK and where his eyes and body position is..passive, flat footed, hasn't moved up, and is ball watching. Sami comes in because BK is on the inside shoulder of Suaali.

Sami could stay on his winger but then Manu would hit Suaali who would roll through anyway.

I'm not saying Sami takes none of the fault, but I think BK is partly responsible for a lot of the poor defence out wide. This happens a fair bit.

thank you for coming to today's analysis talk
 
Last edited:
Definitely forward out of the hands.......or our defence is just so terrible we can't even mark up when there is no overlap. At least Kelly got some star jumps in while he defends the wrong person.
 
Had some spare time so forced myself to re-watch some of the game last night. Looking at this last try that we (me included) threw a fair bit of shade at Sami for

LtrFQ0E.png


But lets instead focus on BK and where his eyes and body position is..passive, flat footed, hasn't moved up, and is ball watching. Sami comes in because BK is on the inside shoulder of Suaali.

Sami could stay on his winger but then Manu would hit Suaali who would roll through anyway.

I'm not saying Sami takes none of the fault, but I think BK is partly responsible for a lot of the poor defence out wide. This happens a fair bit.

thank you for coming to today's analysis talk

Great post HS.

If kelly had pushed up with the man on his inside he could make the tackle on saulii or atleast slow him down enough whilst help arrived being further out from the try line.

I take back anything I said about sami. It's clear Kelly's defence and positioning is a major issue. It happens every week, when will holbrook drop him?
 
Great post HZ. My only comment on that is Sami is far too infield. Yes BK didn’t push up but look where Sami’s winger is.
I’d be interested to see where both Kelly and Sami were positioned when the play the ball was taken
 
Great post HZ. My only comment on that is Sami is far too infield. Yes BK didn’t push up but look where Sami’s winger is.
I’d be interested to see where both Kelly and Sami were positioned when the play the ball was taken

It's a fair point and but I think if Sami hangs on his winger, Suaali changes from passive-decoy to getting the ball on a hard overs-line and rolls through himself.

This is the nearest frameto the PTB I could get with them both in it.

XNwBC1i.png


Looks even worse for BK. Shoulders in, flat footed (not on his toes), and staring at the ball. I interpret Sami's positioning as being caught between a jam and trying to hold on his opposite because he's confused about Kelly counting starjump reps inside him.

Between the two frames, Ash & Sami move up but BK stays where he is.
 
Last edited:
Sami is trying to half fill the void left by BK not moving up but also trying to mark his winger hence he's in no man's land.

If kelly had moved up quickly onto saulii it would of giving sami the opportunity to be a step or 2 wider to cover his winger

Sami is only trying to cover for Kelly's lack of defensive nous
 
Certainly doesn’t look good for Kelly. Can see why there would be a lack of trust on Sami’s behalf.

Edit: Sami actually started out where he should have been as well. His positioning shows that he intended on squeezing in on Suaali even before Manu had the ball (the second screenshot shows this). Attacking teams much have a field day exploiting this deficiency in our edge defence.
 
Last edited:
BK is easily the biggest disappointment this year.
At the end of last season he was elite and now he’s listless.
Holbrook dropped him early on last year and it got him going again and motivated.
 
Back
Top Bottom